Request information
Humanitarian and Compassionate Considerations

Humanitarian and compassionate considerations in Canada: The assessment criteria

BA

The Blain Avocats Team

Immigration Lawyers

30 October 2026 · 7mins of reading

An application based on humanitarian and compassionate considerations allows, in exceptional circumstances, an exemption from certain standard requirements of Canadian immigration in order to apply for permanent residence in Canada. This pathway is intended for people who do not qualify under any other immigration program, but whose personal situation warrants, according to Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC), a particular review. Here are the criteria that are actually assessed and how the process unfolds, both at the federal level and in Quebec.

If you are considering submitting an application for humanitarian and compassionate considerations, you can consult our page dedicated to this type of application to learn more about the applicable criteria and the options available to you: Application for Permanent Residence on Humanitarian and Compassionate Grounds.

Key Takeaways

  • A humanitarian and compassionate application is an exceptional measure, not a simple alternative to other immigration programs.
  • IRCC assesses all the circumstances specific to each file, including the applicant’s degree of establishment in Canada, the best interests of any child directly affected by the application, and the unusual and undeserved, or disproportionate, hardship the applicant could face if required to leave Canada.
  • Each file is reviewed individually. There is no guarantee as to the outcome of the application, and processing times vary depending on whether the application is submitted in Quebec or in another Canadian province.

What Is an application based on humanitarian and compassionate considerations?

An H&C application allows a person who does not meet the standard criteria for permanent residence to request an exemption due to circumstances deemed sufficiently significant. Unlike a refugee claim, it is not based on a fear of persecution assessed by a tribunal, but on a set of human and personal considerations reviewed in writing by an IRCC decision-maker.

This application also differs from family sponsorship and economic immigration programs in the grounds on which it is based. It allows IRCC to review a person’s particular circumstances and determine whether they justify an exemption from the standard immigration requirements. In practice, it is often a solution considered when other immigration pathways do not make it possible to regularize the applicant’s status. Each application is, however, assessed on its own circumstances.

What factors are assessed in an application based on humanitarian and compassionate considerations?

IRCC reviews the circumstances specific to each application to determine whether they justify granting an exemption from the standard immigration requirements. The assessment is global: no single factor guarantees a favorable decision, and the weight of each varies depending on the applicant’s situation. Certain elements may nonetheless play an important role in the analysis.

Establishment and ties in Canada

IRCC may consider the applicant’s degree of establishment in Canada, including the length of their stay, their employment situation, their language skills, and their participation in social and community life. Family ties developed in Canada are also among the relevant circumstances, particularly when separating family members would have significant consequences.

Documents that concretely demonstrate this establishment, such as proof of employment, volunteer certificates, or letters of support from loved ones, can help illustrate the applicant’s situation and the ties they have built over time.

The best interests of the child

When a decision is likely to affect a child, their best interests must be taken into account in the assessment. This may concern a child living in Canada or abroad. The analysis focuses in particular on the concrete consequences the decision would have on the child’s stability, education, family relationships, and well-being.

It is therefore important to explain the child’s particular situation and the repercussions the contemplated decision would have, supporting these explanations with relevant documents where possible.

Hardship in the event of return to the country of origin

IRCC also examines the unusual and undeserved, or disproportionate, hardship the applicant could face if required to leave Canada. This hardship may relate to their personal situation, their living conditions, health problems, or the circumstances awaiting them in their country of origin.

The analysis depends on the facts specific to each file. The elements put forward must therefore be clearly explained and, as far as possible, supported by concrete evidence, such as medical documents, information on the applicant’s personal situation, or elements establishing the consequences of a return.

These factors do not constitute a closed list. Other relevant circumstances may be taken into consideration depending on the applicant’s situation. The objective is to present a complete and documented picture of their situation, explaining why the circumstances as a whole justify an exemption on humanitarian and compassionate grounds.

The federal process and the quebec component: What are the differences?

An application for permanent residence on humanitarian and compassionate grounds is first reviewed by Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC). For people residing in Quebec, a provincial step is added to the process after approval in principle at the federal level. This particularity involves additional steps and may extend the time required before permanent residence is obtained.

The federal process with IRCC

The application is first submitted to IRCC, which assesses the circumstances of the file to determine whether an exemption on humanitarian and compassionate grounds is warranted. When the application is approved in principle, the process continues toward the steps leading to permanent residence.

The provincial step in Quebec

In Quebec, approval in principle at the federal level allows the applicant to begin the provincial process with the Ministère de l’Immigration, de la Francisation et de l’Intégration (MIFI). The applicant is then invited to submit an application for permanent selection under the program for persons selected on humanitarian grounds.

MIFI assesses the applicant’s situation according to the criteria applicable to the program. When the application is accepted, a Quebec Selection Certificate (CSQ) is issued. The file then continues to be processed by IRCC with a view to permanent residence.

This additional provincial step distinguishes the process applicable in Quebec from that of the other Canadian provinces. It involves additional steps and processing times that are added to those at the federal level.

Have your situation assessed by a professional

A humanitarian and compassionate application rests entirely on the quality of the evidence presented, which makes a personalized assessment particularly useful before beginning the process. Understanding the general criteria is a good first step, but applying them concretely to your situation requires a case-by-case analysis.

If you are thinking of filing an application based on humanitarian and compassionate considerations, an assessment of your file with our immigration law team makes it possible to identify the elements to document as a priority and to approach this process with a clear understanding of the issues specific to your situation.

Your questions about humanitarian and compassionate considerations

Does my humanitarian and compassionate application give me the right to work while it is being processed?

After approval in principle of their application for permanent residence on humanitarian and compassionate grounds, the applicant may apply for an open work permit while their file continues to be processed. This permit is not tied to a specific employer. Issuance of the permit remains subject to the requirements applicable to that application.

What can I do if my application is refused?

A refusal does not necessarily prevent other steps from being taken. Depending on the circumstances, it may be possible to submit a new application based on humanitarian and compassionate considerations, particularly if new elements can be submitted, or to ask the Federal Court to review IRCC’s decision. The choice of approach depends on the reasons for the refusal and the particulars of the file. Since the deadlines for applying to the Federal Court are short, it is important to promptly review the available options.

Do I need to be represented by a lawyer to file my application?

It is not a legal requirement, but H&C applications rest entirely on the quality and precision of the written evidence presented, which makes legal support particularly useful in building a solid file.

How can I update my contact information after filing my application?

You must inform IRCC of any change of address, telephone number, or email address as soon as it occurs, so as not to miss an important communication concerning your file.

What is the difference between my H&C application and a refugee claim?

A refugee claim seeks Canada’s protection when a person fears, in particular, persecution or risks serious harm if returned to their country. It is generally reviewed by the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (IRB). In certain circumstances, the risks associated with removal may also be assessed by IRCC as part of a Pre-Removal Risk Assessment (PRRA).

An application based on humanitarian and compassionate considerations pursues a different objective: it seeks to determine whether the applicant’s personal circumstances justify granting permanent residence despite the standard immigration requirements. The assessment may take into account, in particular, their establishment in Canada, the best interests of any child concerned, and the consequences their departure would entail. Risks of persecution, torture, or cruel and unusual treatment are not, in themselves, factors assessed in an H&C application.

How long should I expect to wait before receiving a response?

Processing times for applications based on humanitarian and compassionate considerations can be long and vary depending on several factors. IRCC regularly updates its processing estimates, which you can consult on its website.

For people residing in Quebec, an additional step with the Ministère de l’Immigration, de la Francisation et de l’Intégration (MIFI) is added after approval in principle at the federal level, which extends the process.

After approval in principle, the applicant is generally eligible to apply for an open work permit while their file continues to be processed.

This article is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Since each humanitarian and compassionate file is assessed individually, a consultation with an immigration lawyer is recommended for any personalized assessment.

Plan a meeting

Request information
19, Rue le Royer Ouest, bureau 200, Montréal, QC H2Y 1W4
T.(514) 288-3348
Monday to Friday 9:00 – 5:00
reception@blainavocats.ca
crossmenu