The best interests of the child are among the factors most closely examined by Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) when assessing an application for permanent residence on humanitarian and compassionate grounds. As soon as a child, whether an immediate or extended family member, is affected by the outcome of the file, that child’s well-being becomes an element the decision-maker must examine with care. This principle, shaped by several decades of Canadian case law, also comes into play in other immigration proceedings. Below are the criteria IRCC applies, the children concerned, and the evidence to gather in order to document this factor.
Key Takeaways
- The best interests of the child are a central factor assessed by IRCC in any H&C application that directly affects a child.
- Canadian case law requires the officer to be alert, alive, and sensitive to those interests, without them being determinative on their own.
- The child concerned may be the applicant’s own child, but also an extended family member, such as a grandchild or a nephew, depending on the relationship of dependency demonstrated.
- Documenting the child’s establishment, schooling, health, and emotional ties strengthens the file.
What are the best interests of the child in an H&C application?
When an application based on humanitarian and compassionate considerations is likely to have consequences for a child, IRCC must take that child’s best interests into account when assessing the file. The analysis focuses in particular on the impact the decision would have on the child’s stability, development, education, and family relationships. The weight given to these elements depends on the child’s particular situation and on the concrete consequences the contemplated decision would entail.
A principle shaped by Canadian case law
The Supreme Court of Canada defined the contours of this principle in Baker v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), [1999] 2 SCR 817. The officer assessing an H&C application must be “alert, alive and sensitive” to the best interests of the child. Kanthasamy v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), rendered by the Supreme Court in 2015, reinforced this principle and clarified how it applies to immigration files. These two decisions remain important for understanding how this factor must be analyzed.
An important factor, but not determinative on Its own
The best interests of the child are among the elements the decision-maker must weigh, without automatically outweighing the other considerations in the file. A child’s best interests do not take precedence over the other factors examined in an H&C application. In practice, this means that a well-prepared file should present the child’s interests alongside the other elements to be considered, such as establishment in Canada or family ties, rather than relying on that single factor.
Which children are covered by this assessment?
IRCC must take into account the interests of any child directly affected by the decision, whether or not that child is the applicant’s own. This definition is broader than it may appear and covers situations where the connection to the applicant is not a parent-child relationship.
The applicant’s own dependent child
The most common case involves the applicant’s own child, whether living in Canada or abroad. The child’s age, schooling, state of health, and ties to Canada will be examined to determine the consequences a refusal would have on their situation.
Extended family children recognized in certain files
The family relationship between the applicant and the child directly affected does not need to be a parent-child relationship; a grandparent, for example, could be the primary caregiver affected by the decision. An extended family child, such as a grandchild or a nephew who is financially supported, may therefore be taken into account when a genuine relationship of dependency is demonstrated. These situations are often underdocumented in H&C files, even though they can constitute a ground in their own right when properly substantiated.
Which factors does IRCC take into account?
Each situation is assessed individually, but certain elements generally recur in the analysis.
The child’s age is a starting point, as it influences their degree of dependency and their ability to adapt to a change of country. Establishment in Canada is equally significant: the length of residence, the social network, and the child’s educational path make it possible to measure the extent of the repercussions of a potential departure.
Schooling also holds an important place in the analysis, particularly when documentation demonstrates the continuity and stability of the child’s educational path. The child’s state of health is likewise considered, especially when medical follow-up or special needs could be compromised by a relocation.
Family and emotional ties also come into play, whether through cohabitation with the applicant or through letters of support demonstrating the nature of the relationship. Finally, conditions in the country of origin are examined to assess the potential impact of removal on the child, notably in terms of safety and access to education or health care.
None of these factors is determinative on its own. It is the combination of the elements demonstrated, and the way they are documented, that allows the officer to concretely assess the consequences of a decision on the child.
How to document the best interests of the child in your H&C file
The information provided about the child serves to explain the child’s situation and the consequences the decision could have on their well-being. Depending on the circumstances, documents or testimony may support the elements presented, but the analysis is based above all on each child’s particular situation.
Evidence to gather
The child’s situation may be explained using various elements, depending on the circumstances: information about their schooling, their health, their family environment, or the ties they maintain with the applicant. These elements provide a better understanding of the child’s personal situation and of the consequences the decision could have on their well-being.
Elements to consider for a strong file
An H&C application may be refused even when the child’s interests are well documented, since this factor is added to other elements assessed as a whole. Understanding the most frequent reasons for the refusal of an H&C application often makes it possible to anticipate gaps in a file before it is submitted and to make the necessary corrections.
The lawyer’s role in the assessment of this factor
An immigration lawyer assists in structuring the evidence surrounding the best interests of the child, an exercise that requires translating a human situation into concrete, verifiable elements for the decision-maker. This assistance generally falls within the broader scope of immigration law services, which cover all proceedings related to temporary residence, permanent residence, and humanitarian grounds. Well-structured evidence, grounded in the factors recognized by IRCC and the applicable case law, remains the best way to faithfully reflect the reality of the child concerned.
Your questions about the best interests of the Child in an H&C application
Does having a child increase my chances in an H&C application?
The presence of a child affected by your situation may be an important element in the assessment of your application. IRCC must take into account the best interests of any child directly concerned. The weight of this element, however, depends on the specific circumstances of your file and on the repercussions the decision could have on the child.
Can my nephew or grandchild be taken into account in my application, even if they are not my child?
Yes. The relationship with the child does not need to be a parent-child relationship. A grandchild, nephew, or niece whom you care for or support may be considered if that relationship of dependency is properly demonstrated.
What documents should I provide to show that my child would be affected by my removal?
School records, medical follow-up documents, letters from people involved in the child’s life, and evidence of your emotional or financial ties are generally the most useful. The important thing is to explain concretely how the child would be affected, not merely to mention their existence.
If I clearly demonstrate my child’s interests, will my H&C application be automatically approved?
No. The best interests of the child are an important factor, but they are added to other elements of the file that are assessed as a whole. An application may be refused even when this factor is well documented.
Am I required to be represented by a lawyer to address my child’s situation in my application?
It is not a legal requirement, but legal assistance helps structure the evidence and present the child’s interests clearly and with proper support, which can make a difference in the analysis of the file.
How can I prove my ties to my child if they live far from me, in another country?
Letters of support, documented regular communication, and evidence of financial support can illustrate a genuine relationship despite the distance. The important thing is to demonstrate the nature and continuity of that relationship, not merely its existence.