This content provides general information and does not constitute legal advice. Every situation is unique: consult an authorized representative before making a decision.
An asylum claim rests on the facts that make it possible to understand why a person fears returning to their country and why they need Canada’s protection. Preparing the file therefore requires particular attention, notably to ensure the consistency of the information submitted and to present clearly the events that gave rise to the claim.
Certain mistakes can complicate the review of the file or raise questions at the hearing before the Refugee Protection Division (RPD) of the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (IRB).
Points of attention at the main stages of the refugee claim
IRCC or the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) is involved in the initial stage of the refugee claim, notably to determine its eligibility and refer the file to the IRB when the conditions are met. The Refugee Protection Division then reviews the claim and decides whether the person may obtain Canada’s protection.
From the very beginning of the process, the information provided in the forms and the narrative must be prepared with care. Below are some mistakes that warrant particular attention.
1. Overlooking the information entered in the refugee claim summary
The refugee claim summary contains important information about the claimant’s background, including their employment history, previous addresses, and travel. This information must be consistent with what is presented in the narrative and the other documents in the file.
For example, a period of employment declared in the summary may appear incompatible with the dates mentioned in the narrative. Likewise, addresses or periods of residence that differ from one document to another may raise questions during the review of the file.
It is therefore important to carefully reread the summary and compare it with the other information submitted. If an error or discrepancy is identified, it should be corrected or explained appropriately rather than left unaddressed.
2. Presenting a narrative that lacks precision
The narrative is a central component of the refugee claim. It must make it possible to understand the events experienced, the people involved, the circumstances in which the facts occurred, and the reasons why the claimant fears returning to their country.
A narrative that is too general may leave important questions unanswered. Stating that one was subjected to threats, violence, or pressure is not always enough to convey what happened. It is important to specify, as far as possible, when and where the events took place, who was involved, what was said or done, and what the consequences were for the claimant.
Nor should one assume that it will be possible to add all the missing details at the hearing. Testimony may help clarify certain points, but the initial narrative must already present, clearly enough, the essential facts on which the claim rests.
If an exact date cannot be established, it is preferable to say so honestly and to situate the events as precisely as possible, rather than to provide an uncertain date as if it were certain.
3. Submitting contradictory information or failing to explain discrepancies
Consistency in the file does not mean that every document must use exactly the same words. It does, however, require that the essential information can be understood as a whole.
Discrepancies between the summary, the narrative, the forms, and the supporting documents may lead the IRB to request explanations. Their significance depends in particular on the nature of the information, its connection to the grounds of the claim, and the explanations provided.
Where a difference exists, it is important not to attempt to conceal it or to artificially alter one’s narrative to make it match the other documents. Instead, one should identify where the discrepancy comes from and be able to explain it honestly.
Preparing your file carefully
Before submitting a refugee claim, it is useful to reread all the information provided and to verify that the narrative clearly presents the essential events. Particular attention should be paid to dates, periods of employment, addresses, travel, and any other information that may be compared across several places in the file.
Thorough preparation does not guarantee that the claim will be accepted. It does, however, make it possible to present the facts clearly and consistently and to be better prepared for the questions that may be raised during the process.
A lawyer with experience in refugee law can help review the file, identify discrepancies, and prepare the claimant for the various stages of the procedure.
After filing: Contact information and follow-up on the file
After a refugee claim has been filed, it is important to keep one’s contact information up to date with the authorities and to comply with deadlines and notices to appear. A change of address or an oversight in following up on the file can have consequences for the proceedings.
Change of address
Any change of address or contact information must be communicated to the relevant authorities, including the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (IRB) and Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC), depending on the stage of the file.
One should not assume that a change reported to one authority will automatically be transmitted to the other. Keep proof of the changes made and check your email regularly so as not to miss any important communication.
Failure to appear or to meet a deadline
It is essential to appear when summoned and to meet the deadlines set for submitting the required documents, including the Basis of Claim Form (BOC Form).
Failure to appear at a hearing or to comply with certain procedural obligations may result in abandonment proceedings.
If you are unable to appear when summoned or if you realize that you have missed a deadline, it is important to act quickly in order to determine the available options.
Seeking legal support for your refugee claim
Legal support makes it possible to review each stage of your file methodically, from preparing the forms to following up on communications. Every situation is unique and no outcome can be guaranteed. To learn about all the available options, contact us today.